Input: Schweigen ist Gold – wann du besser einfach die Klappe hältst
Schweizer Radio und Fernsehen (SRF) 10/11/23 - 27m - PDF Transcript
Yeah.
Hello?
Is anyone here?
No panic.
We just went for a short swim.
Swim?
And that's what's going on in this input folk.
And don't worry.
I'm not going to swim for half an hour or so.
But here at the beginning it starts with a bass with a swim arrangement and then everyone
experiences swim again.
Because something happens with us when we experience swim.
In the sense that my podcast app is hanging or I didn't arrive.
What's wrong?
Swim does something with us.
And that's what I want to look at next.
I ask, why does swim irritate at the first moment?
If this break takes longer than 1.5 seconds, we usually get a little nervous and start
to intervene.
And to limit it, it's not about the meditative swim where a week goes by in a monastery,
swim and think to yourself, that you shouldn't go there.
I'm looking for everyday situations where swim is better than blablabla.
I just feel like I'm getting back into situations where swim is more important.
Situations where silver is spoken and swim is gold.
Although there's nothing to say about it, it's connected with an incredible intimacy.
I want to swim, which is often a little deeper in communication.
I want to swim to give it a chance.
I'm looking for the good side of swim.
In point.
It's been a few weeks.
At the end of the meeting, we had a cold.
The voice was a little scratchy.
But otherwise, over a mountain.
And afterwards, it's clear, yes, I'm going to keep drinking tea, stay at home,
read a book or leave a podcast.
Because I've already done this, I'm drinking beer, I have a loud concert, bad air.
And I've talked too long, too loud.
And that was the second concert, two weeks after that.
It was a mistake.
My voice was so scratchy that I swiped a day today.
I looked at the internet afterwards.
I was at home.
And then it helped me somehow and I don't know what else.
But mainly, the voice is beautiful in that way.
You don't need it. Swim.
And now I'm going to talk to you again for the first time.
For the recording of the whole set.
I had a family business, so I had to handle the household with the kids at home.
It was a real challenge.
I tried to talk as little as possible.
And then it got a little bit worse.
And then it was quite sad.
And then it went pretty well.
I really didn't say anything on that day.
So during the whole day, certainly less than anything else,
only until this input episode.
And then on that day, I noticed,
swiping is actually a pretty power tool.
If I saw something today,
because it didn't change,
then these very few words
outside of the swiping
really had a bigger impact on me
than what I talked about the whole day.
I'm just starting to record one.
Okay, let's get started.
This is the German language expert,
Sina Lautenschläger.
She studies swiping for five years.
She tells me that swiping
has a completely different meaning
depending on the place in the world,
or a completely different weight.
There are swiping and swiping cultures.
We in Europe are swiping cultures.
Other than the North European countries,
for example Finland, Sweden,
they belong to swiping cultures.
And the Asian countries
are basically belong to swiping cultures.
Now, what does it mean?
Swiping and swiping cultures
look like
swiping cultures.
There are so-called talkers,
so you call it turn-taking.
And in every conversation,
you always get to a point
where you can use the right to talk.
Often it's about taking a break.
In talking cultures,
you realize that this turn-taking,
that this break before taking the right to talk,
if it's longer than 1.5 seconds,
that doesn't sound like much,
but you like to take a break
in your own conversations
from 1.5 seconds to swiping.
That can really be hell.
If this break in talking cultures
takes longer than 1.5 seconds,
we usually get a little nervous
and try to underline the risk of swiping
and start intervening.
For example, we ask the question
just as we asked you
or we formulate it
or we say,
hello, haven't you listened to me?
In talking cultures,
these breaks are much longer
and based on these breaks,
you have set up this theory
that one is a swiping culture
and the other is a talking culture.
Okay, I've never thought about it
but it also means
that if we talk to someone
from a swiping culture
and it's too early to take a break in the morning,
that it can irritate the other.
So, while with us,
it's unhappily
and if it's too long to take a break
or to pause,
in talking cultures,
it's unhappily if you start talking too early.
So, if you think about the break
and start talking too early
like, hey, haven't you listened to me?
Didn't you understand me? Should I ask the question again?
Then, so to speak,
people from
for example North-European countries
basically giggled or swiped over the mouth
because, so to speak,
they were talking too early in the morning.
Okay. So, first of all,
in what cultural context
do we swip?
And in our talking culture,
it's already 1.5 seconds
for us to say a pause swiping.
1.5 seconds
is from now
to now.
And of course, there are
a lot of different ways of swiping.
It's a loud hit.
There are also very common ways of swiping
that we wouldn't recognize as swiping
because it's also a form of swiping
that we need
to be able to communicate
and talk to each other.
If they would talk to me at the same time,
they would have a problem
at home.
And that's also a form of swiping
that we wouldn't
want to label as swiping
because it's so self-evident
that we don't want
to use the expression
of swiping at all.
1.5 seconds
is from now
to now.
Okay.
But if we could now
swip in everyday life,
then we would swip a good reaction.
Good morning, Matthias.
The importer, Matthias Digg,
called me up.
We meet
at his home.
I'm 53 years old.
I was a father of two daughters.
He was a secondary teacher.
He worked as a professional school teacher
for 21 years.
He was 8 years old.
And now he works
as a professional officer
at the Swiss Army.
And here I'm proud of
a professional officer
who wants to talk to me
about his experiences with swiping.
I can give you an input
to the subject of prejudices.
But sorry, I'm going to stop.
As I told you,
his experiences with swiping
made him a professional school teacher.
Back to the subject.
Matthias
heard my call about swiping.
He realized that swiping
is an important subject in his life.
That's why he works
consciously with swiping.
And he crystallized for me
that if I put it in consciously,
there are two forms of swiping.
On the one hand,
there are the absolute swiping
that we don't really talk about.
And there is a swiping
that is not necessarily
a quiet swiping,
but rather a
content swiping.
The word content swiping
was mainly used as a professional school teacher.
If someone came with an opinion,
he added,
not commented, not commented,
only asked and talked to people.
In many of these cases
the solution
or the perspective
came from the people
themselves.
That's why I gave
them a kind of advice
that they could
reflect in a reliable environment.
They reflect themselves,
reflect the situation.
And that was something I noticed
that a lot of people
helped.
That's why I came back here.
Another swiping that Matthias
said absolutely
was used when employees
or friends were in very difficult situations.
For example, the death of people
or at least in prison.
A very conscious moment,
no matter where you are
from the bank
or in a restaurant
or in a drink
you are here.
But the actual situation
is not talked about here.
It can really be that
there is silence
and that
there is more value
in it
to know
how we are doing it,
to understand how we are doing it.
It knows that at the moment
it is not so good for me.
And we have to talk about it now
without being dead.
And it was before that
that he swiped with someone
but it didn't work out.
Here he has to know
very, very well.
I think he has to have a certain
lead to the situation
that he thinks about.
That we are now thinking
about the situation
that we can already think about.
And if we swip together
then these are very intense moments.
Although there is nothing
to say about it,
it is connected
to some kind of intimacy.
And if in any situation
someone is going to text you
and lead you to everything
then intimacy can be lost
in Mathias Dicke.
If you have seen everything
that there is to say about the situation
then there is danger
that if you continue to talk
about it
then you will have
commonalities, flatitudes
and I think
it will be like
you want to talk about the situation
and then there
I think
it is a misunderstanding
the feeling of
intimacy that is so important
in this situation
that you can destroy it.
Ok, so you can meet
someone who is in a crisis
and swip very consciously.
I have never done that
but I can imagine
that it can be nice
that can help
just be quiet together.
I have to pay attention
quiet is the wrong word
that we are talking about
when we say
be quiet and swip
that is not the same.
Swiping and being quiet
share the commonality that both are nothing
but swiping is nothing
that is measured by communicative meaning
and being quiet
that communicative meaning is missing.
We are not
around the clock
to communicate
and that is why we are not around
to swip around the clock
but we have
commonalities
that I would like to call
as being quiet.
If you are quiet
at that moment there is no meaning
you may be tired and quiet
but if you move
consciously and send
the same signal
swiping always has some meaning
when we swip we do not talk
but when we swip
we say something.
Matias asked
what is the earth in these situations
for a message to send?
I think the main signal
is
for you here
you can call me back
if you need something
but when it is right
for you
we do not have to go deeper
but I think
the main aspect is
in the signal
when you need me
It sounds really good
and why not
support someone in a crisis
but I can not
imagine it so specifically
just do it
swiping is something
that I would like to say
if you need
you can talk about it
but you can also
swiping
it is clear
that we do not
have to meet again
we are not yet in the 100th detail
we are still in the situation
and so on.
One example is a good friend
of him who has separated
his wife from him
and we are still a bit like Gret
or just for his warning
about the situation
that is why he came to the fire
to reflect on this
and the other two times
we said hello
we said goodbye
and in between it was quiet
and there
I got a press
message from him
that it was a moment
when he appreciated
that
it is someone here
who knows the situation
but we do not have to
discuss it there
who said he had
given a lot of energy
to be able to
do it again
Swiping
you both know
there is nothing to say
but we stick together
in such a context
it is called swiping
of course something completely different
than for example when you are
swiping on a street
when you are fighting
you will swiping
what you never enter
but the context of the fight
is close
people are hurt
it is definitely not a comfortable swiping
just like when you enter a church
you are second
and go into a church
as soon as you enter this church
you will not talk to each other
or just whisper very quietly
because this place of the church
gives such a swiping order
and there you can
remove this swiping
you do not care about me
but the place of the church
or the library
gives you
how to interpret this swiping
the context is
what we
do in a swiping
what we do not read into it
very different interpretations
from the swiping
Matias Tick experienced this
a week before our interview
he had to go to the hospital
because of an operation
and he was in a second room
when I entered this room
and he said
have a good day
wish you a good appetite
he did not have a snorkel
and then I entered
and so on
the first night was operated
and so on
and until the fight
we did not change a word
no word
the elderly person came
to the room one night later
within the first two and a half hours
he knew almost everything
where I would do
and so on
and he gave me a name
where we did not have a word
together
but the quality of this swiping
was completely different
than that
what he did with the elderly neighbor
and then we are back
we knew from the beginning
if there is anything
I can ask the other
he could help me
he could speak
we were together
and because he did not say anything
he did not say anything
but it is true
and the other
for me
it was a burden
now we have heard a lot
about empathic swiping
how to deal with it
how to deal with one person
how to deal with a situation
how to deal with a situation
in a conflict
can you swiping
then it was a solution
and indeed
the importer Anna Tanda
said she would go to a coffee
just black
Anna called
to talk about swiping
I have two children
and
a good
friend circle
I am involved with him
and I am at 80%
in a firm
as the exponent
in the line of service
in the line of media
and she sets her mind
to swiping
I always notice
that when swiping
it is
a fight
or a serious discussion
in the afternoon
when everyone
is screaming
or listening
then I notice
that it makes no sense
and then I prefer to swiping
but what is important
after swiping
maybe two hours
then people are
very open
because
they came down
from their stress
after two hours
and on the other hand
because I have the feeling
they are open
for constructive criticism
from my point of view
it is very good
but how difficult is it
for you in the heat of a fight
to be not fair
the first impulse
would be
to talk to someone
and to bring my argument
and to take it back
Yes, that would be my lesson
I have worked in a firm
for 18 years
and I have experienced a lot
I have seen a lot
and I have noticed
that it is
the wrong reaction
but it is also the wrong reaction
and then
in a conflict situation
if you don't know
the strategy
of taking it back
it could be arrogant
or there would be
direct reactions
in a conflict situation
why do you have
nothing to do with it
No, I don't
I look at the person
and they talk
harshly
and the person will also
notice
I follow
I look at them
and when they are done
I don't just go out
and take it back
I look around
and go
and the person will also notice
that it is
arrogant
and then it will be interpreted
No, this is not an experience
The strategy of the Swiss
is based on the job
for example, with their growing daughters
I have to say
for me
nothing
or for me it would be difficult
to take back
any heated discussion
and at the moment
to say nothing
and yes, that is certainly the main question
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
Is it always like that?
Arnold Rezzer, psychologist and partherapist from Germany, has a different opinion.
He also says that we have to be independent to be able to work together.
I think that this is an important criterion,
from a functioning relationship,
that we can work together,
that we don't have to discuss on German shit,
but we can work together
in a form of, I would say,
a kind of connection,
that can't be reached in this form.
A team-connection to move forward,
as Matthias described before.
Do you agree?
Arnold Rezzer goes on.
He says that we have to do a good job.
Is it really worth talking about it?
Or can we just let it be?
Do we want to save ourselves,
if we just move forward?
That's why his partner,
his partner, doesn't always say everything he thinks.
At the beginning of a relationship,
it's very useful,
where you're asked what you think,
what you feel right now.
With the continuous duration of the relationship,
you should be very careful,
when you're asked what you think,
what you feel right now,
and what you can do on a bright evening,
when you're thinking about the attractive neighbour.
Sometimes, it's really about talking about it
and talking about it.
Input.
And now, shortly before the end,
a look behind the scenes of the Input Podcast.
In this case,
two expert voices have just arrived from Germany.
And now we can ask ourselves,
Hello, Swiss Podcast.
Why don't there be Swiss experts
and experts we can ask?
And then it's like this.
We try to ask as many people
from Switzerland as possible.
But,
or maybe as a listener,
sometimes not aware,
it's quite difficult
to find experts and experts.
The person has to have something to say
and talk to a certain extent.
And most often the most difficult one
has to take time
and be ready to give a public opinion.
For example,
a language expert
who has been studying the subject
for several years,
I didn't find Switzerland.
But a psychologist
who was confused with Switzerland
I only found it in Germany.
So,
if ever possible
from Switzerland
and sometimes
we have to call Switzerland.
Just
once,
Switzerland.
For me,
the small race
in the world of the old days
was a real open-minded person.
Or rather,
an open-minded person.
For me,
Switzerland lost
this negative touch.
Of course,
Switzerland can also
be used as a power instrument.
Switzerland can also be brutal.
But,
as we have heard,
Switzerland
is not always just bad.
Sometimes
Switzerland is
the best answer.
I'm impressed
how conscious Anna
or Matthias
are in Switzerland
and we take
the opportunity
to take a look
at my territory.
That was
the week of input,
feedback
or theme ideas.
Feel free to
send an input
at srf3.ch
or me
directly on Instagram
with the name
Matthias von Marburg.
So,
let's go!
Thank you.
Machine-generated transcript that may contain inaccuracies.
«Input»-Redaktor Matthias von Wartburg sucht nach Situationen, in denen Schweigen die beste Antwort ist. Er findet sie im Büro, im Spitalzimmer oder in der Partnerschaft. Dabei erfährt er auch, dass wir bereits eine Sprechpause von anderthalb Sekunden als Schweigen taxieren.
«Nach anderthalb Sekunden Pause will das Gegenüber in der Regel intervenieren und das Schweigen brechen», sagt die Sprachwissenschaftlerin Sina Lautenschläger. Und weiter: In Nordeuropa oder Asien werde ganz anders geschwiegen als bei uns.
_
(00:00) Intro
(01:54) Zum Schweigen gezwungen
(03:35) Wissenschaft zum Schweigen
(07:10) Schweigen mit Freunden
(17:44) Schweigen im Büro
(21:39) Schweigen in der Partnerschaft
(23:37) Blick hinter die Kulissen von Input
(24:39) Fazit
_
Hast du Feedback, Fragen oder Wünsche? Wir freuen uns auf deine Nachricht an
input@srf3.ch – und wenn du deinen Freund:innen und Kolleg:innen von uns erzählst.
_
Gesprächspartner:innen:
Sprachwissenschaftlerin Sina Lautenschläger
Inputhörer Matthias Dick
Inputhörerin Anna Tanda
Paartherapeut Arnold Retzer
_
Autor: Matthias von Wartburg