Global News Podcast: Urgently needed aid sent to Nagorno-Karabakh
BBC 9/23/23 - Episode Page - 32m - PDF Transcript
Hello, this is the Global News podcast from the BBC World Service with reports and analysis
from across the world. The latest news seven days a week. BBC World Service podcasts are
supported by advertising. This is the Global News podcast from the BBC World Service.
I'm Valerie Sanderson and in the early hours of Sunday the 24th of September these are our main
stories. What now for the Armenian civilians in Nagorno-Karabakh following Azerbaijan's takeover
of the disputed territory. Ukraine says Russian Navy commanders were among those hit in Friday's
missile strike on the headquarters of the Black Sea Fleet in occupied Crimea.
Also in this podcast the long-term consequences of COVID. What we found was that five months
after discharge patients who were previously hospitalized were at three times more likely
to have abnormalities involving multiple organs compared to patients without COVID-19.
And how is French cinema managing to survive with only one in 50 films covering its production costs?
It's less than a week since Azerbaijani forces captured the disputed enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh
in a lightning operation. Since then there have been increasing concerns for the welfare of
the territory's ethnic Armenian population. Many of them were displaced in the fighting and have
taken refuge in the main city Stepanikert. The local authorities say the terms of a ceasefire
are being implemented including the delivery of humanitarian aid and the disarming of Armenian
separatists. But food and medicine are running low and power cuts are frequent. Media access to the
region has long been tightly controlled by the authorities but the BBC has been allowed in
under the close watch of an Azerbaijani military escort. BBC Russians Olga Ivshina sent us this report.
This is the first time journalists have been allowed into Karabakh since the start of recent
hostilities. We're currently in Shusha, a key point in the area. It sits on a mountain which
overlooks several strategic roads and towns. The conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia has taken
tens of thousands of lives. Azerbaijan military has told us they're currently in control of
Hankendi which Karabakh Armenians call Stepanikert and consider their capital so it's very important.
However, Azerbaijan has provided no details, no evidence and this is as close as we are allowed to go.
The biggest question now is what happens to Karabakh Armenians who have lived here for several decades.
An Azeri official has just told me that they will only target armed rebels and they're ready to
provide security guarantees for the civilians. We're currently conducting mine cleaning. We also
established camps, temporary camps. In these camps we can provide food, water, electricity and those
heating up to one thousand people in each camp. However, there is a lot of mistrust on both sides.
Destiny of these people is now de facto in Azeri hands. Olga Ivshina. The BBC has also spoken to
Sirenish Sargasyan, a journalist who lives in Stepanikert and she says the situation there is dire.
The thing is that we can't feel safe for our lives in this situation. We can't have any kind of hope
if I even want to leave. Who will allow me? Sorry, but I don't believe that this talk about humanitarian
corridor which will provide us, it's not possible in this condition. Azerbaijan has a green light
from this international community, from Russia, from UK, from other European countries and of course
from US. I got more from our caucuses correspondent Rehan Dmitri who's monitoring the situation from
Georgia. In Stepanikert, Valerie, where most people are concentrated now, I'm talking about
thousands of people who were displaced by this latest military offensive from Azerbaijan. They are
now in Stepanikert in basements, in shelters. Some pictures have emerged from Sirenish whose
voice we just heard. She's managing to post some photographs and those pictures show no electricity,
very little food, lots of uncertainty, fear and really, really desperate kind of situation for
people because on top of that there are lots of people who are still missing and the local human
rights ombudsman earlier today reported that they have received 600 calls from people who are still
looking for their relatives, including children. And do we know how many separatists have been
disarmed and how many remain? Well, the process of disarmament is ongoing. There's no specific
number of how many were disarmed, but today the Azerbaijani Ministry of Defense published a list
of military equipment that has been seized so far, so this process is ongoing. Now, there's a US
senator, Gary Peters, who has visited the border. He is saying that international observers are needed
to monitor the situation there. Is there any evidence of that kind of international monitoring yet?
Not yet, but there are more and more calls for international monitors because of course there
are fears of ethnic cleansing. This is something what Armenia has been saying for a long time.
And given the history of this conflict that three years ago when Armenia and Azerbaijan fought a
full-scale war, and you know, we live in a digital age, so horrible videos showing the mistreatment
of Armenian prisoners of war that was all happening three years ago, so the fears that these atrocities
might be repeated are justified, I think. Rehan Dimitri. Ukraine has claimed that Russian commanders
were among those injured in Friday's missile strikes on the Black Sea Fleet headquarters
in occupied Crimea. The head of Ukrainian military intelligence said the attack killed
at least nine people. Danny Ibrahim has more details. Evidence is building that Russia's
naval headquarters sustained significant damage. More video footage appears to show a follow-up
missile striking the already damaged building, causing a large explosion.
Kirill Obradov told Voice of America that two Russian generals, including one involved in
operations in the Zaporizhia region, had been badly wounded. Ukraine's special forces say the
strikes were timed to target a meeting of the leadership of the Russian fleet. Neither source
has provided evidence for their claims, which have not been independently verified. The
Sevastopol area has come under renewed attack this morning. Russia's top official there said
debris from a missile shot down by air defences had fallen near a pier. He's also tried to calm
residents, warning people to stop sowing panic and, in his words, delighting our enemies.
It's clear from his post on social media that some in Sevastopol have had problems accessing bomb
shelters. Danny Eberhard. What are the long-term effects of COVID-19? The pandemic began three
and a half years ago. Now a new study of 259 people who were hospitalised with the infection
found they were far more likely to show damage to major organs than people who never caught it.
Professor Betty Riman of Oxford University is the lead author of the study, published in the
Lancet Respiratory Medicine Journal. What we found was that five months after discharge, patients
who were previously hospitalised were at three times more likely to have abnormalities involving
multiple organs on MRI compared to patients without COVID-19. The biggest impact was seen in
the lungs, but we also found abnormalities involving the brain and the kidneys.
And were these people displaying symptoms of long COVID, and if so, what were they?
So we did not specifically study patients with long COVID, but we know that approximately 70%
of patients who were previously hospitalised may continue to have ongoing symptoms five months
from infection. So the majority of our patients were not completely recovered from the infection.
And I guess one important thing is that many of the things you picked up in these MRI scans were
without symptoms, so people wouldn't even know they had a problem.
Yes, that's correct. People could have these changes and not have any symptoms. One organ,
however, where there was a link was the lung. So if there were changes involving the lung,
people were more likely to experience chest tightness and cough. But it was surprising
that we couldn't see a similar association in other organs. Now, these were people, as you say,
that were hospitalised, so fairly severely ill. What about the many people who were pretty ill at
home for several weeks? What can you learn from this study of anything about those people?
It's possible that some of the findings that we're seeing in the post-hospitalised group
may be seen in a small number of people who did not come into hospital. That said, there have been
follow-up studies of individuals with long COVID who did not require admission to hospital, and
these studies have undertaken multi-organ MRI scans. And it seems like the pattern of changes
were different. Those who required hospitalisation had a higher prevalence of lung MRI abnormalities.
And what are the implications of your findings for health services around the world?
There are two important implications from our work. The first is that people who continue to
feel unwell after they were hospitalised from COVID-19 do need a more comprehensive checkup
where the doctor pays attention not just to the lungs, but also to the brain and the kidneys.
The second is that we have identified some risk factors for multi-organ changes and abnormalities,
and these include older age and comorbidities. So individuals from this vulnerable group should
stay up to date with the COVID-19 vaccination programme available to them.
Do you think the problem of long COVID is being underestimated or are we across it?
I don't think we have a good idea yet of the real burden of long COVID across the community
because of reduced efforts to study this.
Professor Betty Rabin Think of French films and you may conjure up
a vision of Brigitte Bardot or Alain Delon in all their 1960s glory. But a report by the French
body that examined the value for money of projects and organisations in receipt of government funding
has revealed that just 2% of present-day French films make enough money at the Global Box Office
to cover their production costs. In fact, the industry survives thanks to generous state subsidies.
Adam Sage is the Times Paris Correspondent and Caroline White asked him
when French films really were at their zenith.
The years of Truffaut, 60s, 70s, maybe the Golden Age, maybe Eric Cromer as well in the 1970s.
These films such as Le Cade son Coup or something like that were really the highlights of French cinema.
La Piscine without Alain Delon, I mean these were the films that marked a generation of
French filmgoers and no doubt outside France as well.
Are French films losing their magic because it seems from those figures that French cinema
goers are not smitten anymore? I mean a few French films are certainly still retain the magic. The
last pan d'or winner at the Cannes Film Festival at Anatomédian Shoot is doing very well. But an
increasing number of films are being made year after year and an increasing number of those
films are attracting almost no one to see them. We're talking about an awful lot of films that
have been massively subsidised that are really not finding a public to watch them.
And yet this is something that certainly some French film directors have said is a good thing.
Yes, that's right. I mean this is an exception on Couturelle, the cultural exception, which is that
you have a cinema industry that is heavily subsidised that doesn't need to worry about
profitability and box office the same way that Hollywood does that can explore intellectual
and artistic and cultural paths. And a lot of people in France in the French cultural sector
would say this is a positive thing. I mean it is true that the system of subsidies has kept a
fairly lively cinema sector going in France. When French people go to the cinema they do tend to
watch more often French films than say the British watch British films or the Italian Italian films.
So that's absolutely true. But there is certainly a worry amongst let's say people who are less
interested in culture, more interested in public finances about the amount of money that's going
into the cinema and the amount of money that's going into cinema to make films that are really
not attracting anyone to speak of. And does this worry the French themselves or do they think it
is worth it simply to carry on producing the films? No, I don't think that French are waking up in
the middle of the night worrying about this to be honest. It hits the headlines in May at the Caen
Film Festival because Justine Trié, who is the director of the winner, Annette Amidoune Choudre,
she used her acceptance speech to say that the French system was being threatened by President
Macron's quote-unquote neo-liberal government. Now I don't see any evidence that it is being
threatened or indeed that President Macron really has a neo-liberal government. But it did put the
issue into the news agenda and there was a debate about if the government said nonsense, you're
getting lots of money and you're being very ungrateful. And I think that a number of French
people probably agreed with that. But then it came and went and no one seriously was saying we should
pull the plug from under the cinema industry and stop the subsidies that they're getting.
It's a very, very marginal point of view in France.
And that was Caroline White speaking there to Adam Sage in Paris.
The 19th Asian Games have been opened by President Xi Jinping in China in front of a stadium packed with
tens of thousands of spectators. The event, which takes place over the next two weeks,
has cost billions of dollars, with sporting teams from North Korea, Afghanistan and Syria
all involved. The BBC's Jason Lee has more details.
It's the biggest sporting event in Asia. It's sort of like the Olympics of Asia for those who
are not familiar with it. And the Hangzhou Games this year is also the biggest sporting event hosted
by China in more than a decade. That's because in terms of the scale of the competition, it's even
bigger than the Winter Olympic Games held in Beijing last year in the capital because it was
under strict COVID zero policy then. This year more than 12,000 athletes from all 45
national Olympic committees in Asia and the Middle East will participate competing in 40 sports.
Now, these include some of those that originated from the region and which are not included in the
Olympic Games, such as the Dragon Boat Racing and the Chinese martial arts Wushu.
It's the first time, isn't it, in three years that a team from North Korea is attending. Why not?
Well, in recent months, we've seen some signs that North Korea might be slowly opening up.
It's borders since it sealed them three years ago in wake of the pandemic. So last month,
we saw a group of North Korean Taekwondo athletes. We believe them to be Taekwondo athletes crossing
the border into China. And this was the first time that Pyongyang sent a sports team abroad since
2020. So North Korea sending its athlete to the Hangzhou Games might be the continuation of that.
Another point I want to highlight is North Korea being one of the most isolated countries in the
world has been quite keen on sports diplomacy. So by participating in the Games, North Korea
might be signalling it's ready to pursue that again. And of course, Beijing is a close ally
of North Korea and being neighbors, Pyongyang might have thought that there was less political
as well as logistical pressure to send its team to Hangzhou.
Well, you've brought up politics. It's interesting looking at the guest list because
there are people there, political leaders who certainly would not be invited to sporting events
like the Olympics, would they? Definitely, that's true. So one notable example is the
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. It's his first visit to China since the war erupted in Syria in
2011. So it's another sign that the Syrian President who's been shunned on the world's diplomatic
stage for more than a decade might be slowly being welcomed to the world stage after he attended
the Arab League Summit earlier this year in Saudi Arabia.
Jae Sung Lee. Still to come on the Global News Podcast?
It's exploitation beyond all logic. Women's bodies are reduced to objects that can be rented for nine
months. Is Italy about to ban people from traveling abroad to have children through surrogacy?
This weekend sees the beginning of the new academic year in Iran, but it's been overshadowed by
controversy. Several teachers' organizations have issued statements criticizing the atmosphere in
schools and the pressure on their members. A year after the start of anti-government protests which
prompted a violent crackdown by the security forces, teachers have also expressed their
own happiness about the alleged poisoning of students in schools across the country.
Our Middle East analyst, Sebastian Usher, told me more about the protests and what's happening
in Iran's schools.
I mean it's fair to say that the young generation in Iran were really at the forefront of the protests
for ones which were set off by the death of a young Iranian Kurdish woman, Musa Amini,
in the custody of the Moranti police just over a year ago. And we've seen in the universities,
we've seen a lot of professors have been sacked there, a lot of students were barred from attending
courses and it seems that that has moved towards schools where much younger pupils as young as
14, 15 were going out on the streets, lots of young girls who were essentially throwing off their
headscarves at the height of the protests back in the spring of this year and really making
their voices heard, trying to say that the generation that they're part of no longer accepts for
rules and regulations, but have been in place for four decades since the Islamic Revolution
in Iran. Those protests have basically calmed down as far as people going out on the streets
are concerned. There's still defiance, quite widely, but people express online also to some
extent in public by not wearing headscarves. So this is an interesting moment in the schools
to see just how strongly the authorities will react in this new academic year. I mean I've
seen a report that the Minister of Education has said that a very large number of thousands of school
principals are going to be replaced and that they essentially want people running the schools who
are very much in line with what the authorities believe and in preserving the rules and regulations
that have been in place for so long. We've seen a number of teachers who have been suspended,
some have been arrested. That's not just to do the protests over Masa Amini and the controversy
over the headscarf. It's also that they've been long-running strikes by teachers as there have
been by other professionals that their living standards are being degraded as inflation rises.
So you know this is a major issue. Add to that also the school poisonings that happen that still
haven't been resolved properly. So this will be an interesting year to see where this all goes.
Sebastian Usher. In Italy a law has been proposed by Prime Minister Georgia Maloney's right-wing
government which would criminalise people who travel abroad to have children with the help of a
surrogate. The gay community says it's a deliberate attempt to stop same-sex couples having children
but this has been denied. It's likely the law will be passed making surrogacy via foreign countries
a universal crime as it's known in Italy. That would carry a fine of a million dollars
and up to two years in prison. A correspondent Sophia Petitza has this report.
I grew up here in Italy. This is a country where the influence of the Catholic Church has always
been strong. Gay marriage is illegal and same-sex couples have fewer rights than in most of Western
Europe. Surrogacy, artificial insemination or adoption are all against the law here. So if
LGBT couples want to have a baby their only option is to go abroad.
Like Mauro and Maurizio they've been together for 20 years. Their twins Giorgio and Luisa
are eight months old. They were born in America through surrogacy. We considered to adopt
but in Italy it's impossible to adopt for a gay couple. To be son of a universal crime is a stigma
on our children. What exactly is a universal crime? It's a crime so serious that it's prosecuted even
if committed abroad. But that is usually human trafficking, pedophilia or war crimes. It seems
odd that surrogacy, which is legally many countries, would fall under this category.
I wanted to speak to someone in government about all of this. So I've come to the Italian
parliaments to meet Carolina Varchi, the MP who drafted the surrogacy bill.
Surrogacy needs to be discouraged and opposed. It's exploitation beyond all logic. Women's
bodies are reduced to objects that can be rented for nine months. I pointed out to her that many
see her bill as an attack on the LGBT community. Absolutely false. Most people who use surrogacy
are heterosexual. This is a law that protects women and their dignity. We're on our way to
meet two men who are expecting a baby through surrogacy. They are really scared of what could
happen to them and their baby. So they've asked us not to reveal their identities.
If Carolina Varchi's bill is passed before their baby is born, they could face severe consequences.
It's put a huge strain on them, doing a conversation one plays the piano while the other one paints.
I'm afraid that our child won't have his parents because their parents are in jail.
So do you feel like you're having to seek political asylum? Yes, I'm feeling like we have
to be ready to escape as quick as possible and being exiled for having done something which
is actually normal without exploiting anybody. Exploitation is the accusation often used against
these couples, but they say they have a great relationship with their surrogate. A few weeks
ago she sent them a letter and a teddy bear. Congratulations on your baby boy. We are so grateful
you chose us to go on this journey with you. This is a very special bear. It was written
like a hug it and we were like why should we hug it? Then we hugged it and there was a sound
indeed of the heartbeat. Wow that's amazing, no? This is a symbol of everything of the journey
so we're not doing anything bad. That report by Sofia Batica. In the latter half of the 18th century
when he was just 13 years of age Kwobna Atoba-Kagwano was enslaved in what is now Ghana in West Africa
and shipped to the Caribbean island of Grenada. He was eventually taken to England where he was
granted his freedom becoming a campaigner against slavery. Kwobna was baptized in St James's church
in London almost exactly 250 years ago. To mark the anniversary the church has unveiled specially
commissioned paintings in its entrance by an artist from the Caribbean and Martin Benout went along to have a look.
So I'm in St James's church in Piccadilly in the heart of London. St James's is a beautiful 17th
century church and a haven of peace which was built by the architect Sir Christopher Wren
and I'm with the Trinidadian artist Che Lovelace. Che tell us about these pieces of work that you've
done here. The paintings depict a kind of idea of baptism using my own environment and experiences
as a Trinidadian, somebody in the Caribbean. I've used the idea for washing at the river
as the first panel. So we see two people actually washing themselves in the river and some very
colorful plants around them, leaves and lots of greens and blue and turquoise. Yeah I wanted to
bring that to London and into this space. What does the next painting show? Describe it for us.
This one is a female figure. She's submerged underwater swimming. She is very calm. Of course
again I saw this immersion in the water as also symbolic of baptism but also symbolic of the
middle passage across the Atlantic. The third panel I wanted to include something that was musical
and that involved bodies and movement. I thought the drum actually when I first came to St James
church there was a drummer and I thought that would be a good way to kind of connect with the church
as well as connect with the traditions of dance and music. And moving on to the fourth and final
panel what do we see on that? I wanted this one to be devoid of human figures so I wanted it to
feel almost like a visitation painting, visiting something divine, the hummingbirds and the flora,
the coconut trees. They're just the strength and majesty of nature I guess. Also the native
Trinidadian Indians held as a belief that the spurts of ancestors resided in these particular
birds. How did it feel when you've got this commission? That was very moved. Every person of
color especially would connect with the history of the slave trade and the story of Africans in
that time. And we're also joined by the rector of St James's. Hello yes my name's Lucy Winkett.
Could you tell us a bit more about Ottobar Pugwano's life? The only date and time that we can
ascribe to his life is the 20th of August 1773 which was his baptism here at St James's church
Piccadilly. He was 16 years old according to the baptism register and he'd been kidnapped aged 13
from West Africa, traffic to Grenada, worked in a plantation and then was brought here to London
and was freed. And why did you commission this work? Why did the church commission this work?
We realized that the 250th anniversary was coming. We also realized that Ottobar Pugwano is the least
well-known of a group of abolitionists in London at that time called the Sons of Africa who worked
with William Wilberforce who is very well known. And so we thought that one of the best ways to do
that was to put a plaque in the church which we've done but we also thought that wasn't enough.
His book is called The Thoughts and Sentiments on the Evil of Slavery and it was published in 1787
and it's an extraordinary condemnation to the whole practice of slavery. So he's the first
African to call for the total abolition of slavery throughout the world and we wanted to say we must
recognize our complicity with the past and St James's church like every other church of our
generation would have had in its congregation at the time that Pugwano is baptized people who are
benefiting from the transatlantic slave trade. The Reverend Lucy Winkett ending that report by Martin
Venard. And finally a fishing town in northern Japan has decided on a unique way to shift huge
numbers of scallops it's unable to export to China because of a seafood import ban.
Maureen Hokkaido is donating 100,000 portions of the prized shellfish to schools as will Leonardo
reports. Beijing's Japanese seafood ban brought in after the release of wastewater from the wrecked
Fukushima nuclear plant last month appears to have produced an unlikely beneficiary. Students at
several schools across Japan are soon to be treated to a taste of fine dining as the prized
Hokkaido scallops hit their lunch menus. The shellfish have been languishing for a month in
freezers in the northern town of Mori after the loss of the country's biggest international
seafood customer. The town plans to use emergency government money to fund the school offer. It's
just one of many Japanese fishing communities reeling from the blanket Chinese man despite being
hundreds of miles away from where the water used to cool the damage reactors at Fukushima is slowly
being discharged into the sea. Tokyo has announced a package of support for fisheries which are also
paying high storage costs for their products as they seek new customers abroad. The government is
continuing to try to convince its neighbors that the UN approved for Fukushima water release is
safe. The Prime Minister from Yorkshida last month released a video of himself eating raw fish from
near the nuclear plant while the environment minister was recently photographed on a surfing trip in
the area. Will Leonardo reporting and that's it from us for now but there'll be a new edition of
the Global News podcast later. If you want to comment on this podcast or the topics covered in it
send us an email. The address is globalpodcast.bbc.co.uk. You can also find us on X formerly known as
Twitter at Global NewsPod. This edition was mixed by Davith Evans. The producer was Carl Josephs
and the editor as ever is Karen Martin. I'm Valerie Saunderson and until next time bye-bye.
Machine-generated transcript that may contain inaccuracies.
Food supplies arrive in the Armenian-majority enclave after Azerbaijan captured the disputed territory. Also: Ukraine says senior Russian commanders were injured in a missile strike on its Black Sea fleet HQ, and how French film survives despite not meeting its production costs.