Global News Podcast: Israeli scientists grow human-like artificial embryo
BBC 9/6/23 - Episode Page - 30m - PDF Transcript
Hello, this is the Global News podcast from the BBC World Service with reports and analysis
from across the world, the latest news seven days a week. BBC World Service podcasts are supported by
advertising. Ever wondered what the world's wealthiest people did to get so ridiculously rich?
Our podcast, Good Bad Billionaire, takes one billionaire at a time and explains exactly how
they made their money. And then we decide if they are actually good, bad or just plain wealthy.
So if you want to know if Rihanna is as much of a bad gal as she claims, or what Jeff Bezos really
did to become the first person in history to pocket a hundred billion dollars, listen to Good Bad
Billionaire with me, Simon Jack and me, Zing Zing, available now wherever you get your podcasts.
You're listening to the Global News podcast from the BBC World Service.
Hello, I'm Oliver Conway. This edition is published in the early hours of Thursday,
the 7th of September. Scientists in Israel have grown an almost exact replica of a human embryo
without using sperm or an egg. The US has promised more military aid for Ukraine on the day 17
people were killed in a Russian missile attack on a marketplace. And later.
The Rolling Stones are back with a new album.
Also in the podcast, a nationwide manhunt is underway in Britain as a terrorism suspect
makes a rare escape from prison. And four Roman swords believed to have been captured by Jewish
rebels are discovered in a remote cave in Israel. Now, what constitutes life? Will scientists have
managed to create a near exact replica of a 14-day-old human embryo without using sperm,
an egg or a womb? The so-called model embryo contained all the cell types needed to develop
and grow. The scientists from the Weizmann Institute in Israel say their research aims
to shed light on the mysterious but crucial early days after conception. It could lead to new
breakthroughs in preventing early miscarriage and in the development of new technologies for
growing organs for transplant. Lead scientist Professor Jacob Hanna explains how it could help.
We want to make cells for transplantation and we want to be the cells
identical to the patient who receives them. One of the dreams of this technology is say there is
a person who is really about to die because he or she cannot find a bone marrow transplant to take
a skin biopsy, make stem cells, and then differentiate them into this embryo-like model,
let's say for 40 days, and then we can transplant it back to the patient without looking for donor,
without having the risk of rejection because these cells cannot be rejected.
Professor Jacob Hanna of the Weizmann Institute. So, how exciting a moment is this for science?
Our health and science correspondent is James Gallagher.
I think really quite exciting, Oliver. We've had a lot of research, a lot of progress in terms of
trying to do this in the laboratory, but this is the first time that team of scientists has
actually been able to get to the point where they can say, this version of an embryo we have grown
in a laboratory looks pretty much the same as one that would develop naturally, and reaching that
level has caused quite a lot of excitement amongst other scientists and researchers today.
So, pretty much the same. Are there differences or could this grow into a human?
No, and there are many reasons for that. One of them is simply that it's illegal and you would
never be allowed to do this pretty much anywhere in the world that has laws around this area,
would not let you do this. There are also some scientific reasons why we don't think it would
work. So, the way that it is designed, you actually end up missing some of the earliest days of embryo
development, and by the time that it starts to look like something embryo-like, it's probably
missed the opportunity that you could put it into a womb and it would actually embed itself
into the walls of the womb and actually form a pregnancy. So, scientifically there are big
questions there as well. But they have created this amazing replica. How did they do it?
So, traditionally, one sperm meets one egg. They fuse and an embryo emerges, and there are no
sperm or eggs or wombs involved in any of this. So, they use something called stem cells, and
those are the ones that have the capacity to become any type of tissue in the human body,
and they coax those using like subtle chemicals into the four types of cell you would find in a
weak old embryo. And then you mix around about 120 of those together in the laboratory, and it
just looks like a jumbled up mess to start off with. But as they grow over a period of eight days,
they start to organise themselves with no input from scientists. They're doing it all themselves
into something that actually resembles a 14-day-old human embryo, and that's the first time that's
ever happened. Now, in many countries, 14 days is the legal cut-off embryonic research. Could they
get round that and grow these models into older replicas? You're onto a really interesting good
point here, because the legal limit for human embryo research is 14 days in many countries.
These aren't human embryos. There's a legal entity there known as an embryo model,
so they don't have to abide by those same rules. So, technically, if scientists decided they wanted
to, they could attempt to go beyond the 14-day rule and see later stages of embryo development.
Some people would welcome that as a way of studying that period of our development.
Others would be horrified, and I think we're very much in a point where the science has
leapt well ahead of where regulation is anywhere in the world for actually deciding what is right,
what's ethically acceptable, what's legally acceptable, because the closer scientists come
to replicating an embryo in a dish, it will lead many people to ask, well, shouldn't they be treated
in the same way as an embryo? It is a very live ethical debate right now.
A health and science correspondent, James Gallagher.
This Russian evil must be defeated as soon as possible. The words of the Ukrainian president,
as he condemned a Russian attack on a market in eastern Ukraine. The missile strike in the
Donetsk region killed at least 17 people. Ukraine said 32 others were injured while cars and small
shops were destroyed. The strike came as the U.S. Secretary of State Anthony Blinken visited Kiev
to offer more assistance, and given up, beat assessment of progress in Ukraine's counteroffensive
against the Russian invaders. In the years since I was last year, Ukraine has taken back more than
50% of the territory that Russia seized from it since February of 2022. In the current counteroffensive,
we are seeing real progress over the last few weeks. President Zelensky just returned from the
front line, so I was able to hear directly from him his assessment of the counteroffensive, and I
think it very much matches our own. We are doing everything we can to maximize our support to Ukraine
as it pursues the counteroffensive. The U.S. Secretary of State Anthony Blinken in Ukraine.
Well, I heard more about Wednesday's attacks in the east of the country from our correspondent
in Kiev, Paul Adams. This was about two o'clock in the afternoon on a market street in a small town
in eastern Ukraine called Kostyantinivka, not far from Bakhmut, which obviously listeners
will be familiar with. It's a place that's been the target of attacks in the past, but never,
I think, on this scale. We don't know exactly what it was that caused the explosion, but there was a
huge flash of orange fire, an enormous explosion, shrapnel was sent in many directions, and the
scenes afterwards were really pretty horrendous, with buildings set on fire, cars mangled, and a
great many terribly injured bodies lying in the street. So a very graphic and disturbing attack,
which the Ukrainians obviously were very quick to blame on Russia.
Now at the same time as it was feeling the effects of the war, it has had something of a boost from
that visit by Anthony Blinken. Will the Ukrainians be encouraged by the fact that he says there has
been important progress in its counteroffensive? I think he perhaps was anxious to sound positive,
because this comes off the back of a period when a number of generally unnamed American officials
have been quoted in American newspapers suggesting that they were not happy with the progress of
the counteroffensive and that Ukraine wasn't perhaps fighting the way they expected or wanted
them to fight. But of course the other thing that he did, and Mr Blinken was he brought
yet another package of military assistance, this one includes the kind of full range that you would
expect from Ukraine's air defences, which are getting better all the time, through to vast
quantities of ammunition, missiles, shells for tanks, a lot more of the kind of thing that the
Ukrainians have been receiving all year. But despite that extra assistance, President Zelensky
speaking of a harsh winter ahead. I think people are already beginning to think ahead
to what this could be like. There will be vivid memories of last winter. It was actually a
remarkably mild winter, which was very much to Ukraine's advantage, but it was one in which we
saw the Russians of course mounting that sustained attack on Ukraine's energy infrastructure.
I think there's a feeling that Ukraine could be in for more of that. I think there's an acknowledgement
that Ukraine's counteroffensive may not achieve quite as much by the end of the year as everyone
had hoped that it may be that Ukraine has to wait until next year for something more decisive.
And in the meantime, there could be very difficult days ahead, while at the same time feeling
relatively confident and encouraged by the recent signs of progress in the south.
Paul Adams, our correspondent in the Ukrainian capital, Kiev.
At the end of a three-day climate summit in Kenya, African leaders have called for new global
taxes to fund action against global warming. The heads of state say the Nairobi Declaration
will form the basis of their negotiating position at the Worldwide COP28 summit in Dubai later this
year. The Kenyan president, William Ruto, said Africa had to be given the support it needed to
cope with the challenges and harness the opportunities presented by climate change.
We demand a fair playing ground for our countries to access the investment needed to unlock the
potential and translate it into opportunities. Adjust multilateral development finance architecture
to liberate our economies from odious debt and onerous barriers to necessary financial resources.
We are clear in our minds that the international community must work with us in this journey
into a future of prosperity and security in an ecologically parlance thriving planet.
William Ruto, our Africa regional editor, Richard Hamilton has more details.
The declaration includes proposed taxes on shipping, aviation and the trade in fossil fuel,
as well as a global financial transaction tax. African countries have suffered from
heavy debt burdens for years and say they're forced to pay borrowing costs that are five to
eight times higher than those imposed on wealthy nations. However, while some countries in the
world have imposed their own carbon taxes, the idea of a global tax regime has not gained much
traction. Researchers say that despite suffering from some of the worst impacts of climate change,
Africa only receives about 12% of the financing it needs to combat it.
Richard Hamilton. The Catholic Church in Sri Lanka has called for an international investigation
into the 2019 Easter Sunday bombings. After a documentary claim, they were orchestrated to
influence the country's presidential election. Islamists targeted three churches and high-end
hotels, killing more than 270 people. Here's our South Asia regional editor, Anbarasan Etirajan.
The investigative report by the British Channel 4 network featured a Sri Lankan political insider
who accused the current state intelligence chief, Suresh Salli, of complicity in the attacks.
The whistleblower left Sri Lanka last year and has now sought asylum in Europe.
Mr. Salli has denied the accusation and says he was not in the country at the time of the bombings.
He is closely linked to the powerful Rajapaksha clan, two members of which have served as
president of the country. After the documentary was aired, the current Sri Lankan government said
it would appoint a parliamentary committee to look into the latest allegations. Initial
investigations show that local jihadists, inspired by the Islamic State militant group,
carried out the suicide attacks. Gotha Baya Rajapaksha became president in the elections
held in late 2019 after promising to restore security. He was forced to leave office last year
following protests over an unprecedented economic crisis.
Anbarasan Etirajan. Now, rock and roll's great survivors were back center stage in East London on Wednesday.
The Rolling Stones with angry from their first album of original material in 18 years.
Entitled Hackney Diamonds, it will be released next month.
Don't want to be big-headed, but we wouldn't have put this out of our mouth if we hadn't really liked it.
I mean, we didn't want to make just any record and put it out. So we wanted to make records.
Before we went in, we all said we've got to make a record that we really love ourselves.
Other people may like it. Other people may not. But we must say that we are quite pleased with
it. I'm not saying we're big-headed about it, but we're pleased with it. We hope you all like it.
80-year-old lead singer Mick Jagger. Well, the release of the album comes two years after the
death of drummer Charlie Watts. He was replaced by Steve Jordan. And guitarist Keith Richards
spoke about what that meant. Ever since Charlie's gone, it's different. He's number four. He's missing.
He's up there. Thanks to Charlie Watts. Also, we have Steve Jordan, who was Charlie's recommendation
for if anything should happen to him. Steve Jordan's a man. It would have been a lot harder
without Charlie's blessing. Well, our music correspondent Mark Savage was at the album's
launch. I mean, they were playing concerts, festival-sized concerts just last summer.
And then they went straight into the studio, made this album in the space of a month, December
last year. And here they are releasing it, their 24th album, 61 years into their career.
Now, Charlie Watts played on two of the tracks before his death. And they also brought back
former member Bill Wyman, going back to the start almost. Yeah, pretty much. It's 30 years
since Bill Wyman played with the band. And he's there on a song that also features Charlie Watts,
called Live by the Sword. So they said at the press conference today, it's their original rhythm
section back together again. Now Lady Gaga is going to appear on the album, I guess,
following that trend of bringing in modern stars to keeping the sound alive?
Yeah, I mean, it's not like I think Lady Gaga is going to come in and do a guest verse. It's not
going to be the Rolling Stones featuring Lady Gaga. She has that kind of rock voice she can really
belt. So I suspect she'll be holding her own like in a kind of tango with Mick Jagger. And we've also
heard a couple of other guests on there. Paul McCartney is going to play bass on one of the
songs. Stevie Wonder is playing Hammond Organ on the same song that Lady Gaga's on. And Elton
John's on the record as well. So it's an all star cast for this reunion of the Rolling Stones.
Now we all know about when we go to concerts and bands play their old stuff and then they wheel out
some newer tracks and it's never quite as good. Can the Rolling Stones do it? Have other bands
managed to keep relevant? Some people do, don't they? If you think Johnny Cash, his last recording
before he died, they were an incredible revelation and an exploration of his older voice and that
kind of rugged wisdom. David Bowie's final albums, when he was, you know, staring down death after
contracting cancer, they were classic albums. Can the Stones do that? That's what's up for debate
here. The first song that they put out today, Angry, is a real kind of barnstorming radio hit. You
can hear it on the air, but they haven't really had a great album since Some Girls in 1981. So
the jury's out until we hear it next month. A music correspondent, Mark Savage.
Still to come on the Global News Podcast.
As big budget video games make a comeback post COVID, is this the latest hit?
The World Cup winning footballer Jenny Hermoso has filed a legal complaint against the head of
Spanish football over his kiss at the final, as Hermoso alleges that Luis Rubiales' kiss on her
lips was unsolicited, something he contests. I spoke to our correspondent in Madrid, Guy Hedgeko.
Last week, prosecutors in Spain said that they were opening a preliminary investigation to
decide whether there was enough evidence to bring a case against Luis Rubiales for sexual assault
for that kiss that he gave Jenny Hermoso. As part of that investigation, they invited Jenny
Hermoso to make her own accusations and to make a statement against Mr. Rubiales, because without
the alleged victim's statement, they felt the case wouldn't go much further. Now she has done that
before the prosecutor. The National Court can proceed with this case and can investigate with it
further. I think it's significant in the sense that it means that that investigation that was
announced a few days ago, which was sort of probing to see whether things could go any further,
that now is going to proceed. So this is a sort of formalization of that process, and it looks as if
a legal investigation into Mr. Rubiales for sexual assault is going to take place. So it really
confirms that. And of course, the ramifications of that potentially could be very serious for Mr.
Rubiales if it does go to trial. What could he face? He could face charges of sexual assault,
which according to Spanish law, could in theory lead to a jail sentence. Now that's looking
ahead a bit, and it could be some time before it comes to that. But of course, that just adds
to the pressure on Mr. Rubiales, which is already pretty intense and has been for a couple of weeks
now seems extraordinary that he is still clinging on to his job, even though the coach of the women's
World Cup team, Jorge Vilda, has now been sacked. The Federation took that decision in the absence
of Mr. Rubiales, who of course has been suspended provisionally by FIFA football's world governing
body. When the Rubiales affair or blew up and Vilda was seen clapping Mr. Rubiales when he made a
very defiant speech before the Federation, there was a feeling that it was going to be very difficult
for Jorge Vilda to remain in his post because he was seen as such a close ally of Mr. Rubiales,
and yet someone who really didn't have a lot of support within the football team itself.
Guy Hedgeko in Madrid. A manhunt is underway here in Britain after a former soldier charged with
terror offences escaped from a prison in southwest London. Daniel Abed Khalif broke out of Wandsworth
jail where he was awaiting trial on accusations he left fake bombs at a military base. Security
checks have been stepped up at ports and airports. Our correspondent Dominic Casciani has the details.
Daniel Khalifa was due to stand trial in November, accused of the alleged bomb hoax and
eliciting information that could be used for preparing an act of terrorism. He's also accused
of breaching the Official Secrets Act by gathering information that could be useful to an enemy.
At his last court appearance in July, he denied all the charges. Disguised as a chef and clinging
on to the underside of a van, he evaded multiple opportunities to detect his escape from the
Category B prison, the second highest level of security. Commander Dominic Murphy, head of the
Met's counter-terrorism command, said he was confident that Khalifa posed a low risk to the
public but shouldn't be approached. He could be anywhere in the country at the moment, and yes,
of course, we're mindful of the risk of him potentially leaving the country. We're focusing
our efforts in London, so we have cancer terrorism officers now deployed across London,
working with colleagues from across the Metropolitan Police and our partner agencies to try and find
him here. We are also working with colleagues all around the country. The escape immediately
triggered a full lockdown of HMP Wonsworth and a nationwide alert to the border force,
leading to delays for passengers at Heathrow and Manchester airports. Even if the 21-year-old is
found, the incident is incredibly embarrassing. Escapes are very rare. There have only been
five since 2017, and Khalifa is the first terror detainee to evade security since a mass IRA breakout
in 1994. Dominic Casciani reporting. Hollywood has had a close relationship with the Pentagon
for decades. Some films are even given access to real weapons, fighter jets and ships. But now a
congressman wants the law changed to prohibit the Pentagon from helping Hollywood studios,
which edit content to avoid antagonizing the Chinese government. It follows controversies over
the Taiwanese flag in Top Gun and a map of the South China Sea in Barbie. Martha Casciani spoke
to Caj Larson, a military technical advisor who served for 13 years in the US Navy Seals.
There is a long history of cooperation between the Pentagon or the Department of Defense and
Hollywood dating back to World War II to collaborate together to make cinema in order to inform the
American public of things that were happening around the war. That productive relationship
continues to this day, and I've had the privilege to be part of many projects as a producer, actor,
as a stuntman with the Department of Defense to tell accurate and authentic military stories.
You even ended up appearing in Top Gun Maverick, didn't you?
I have to say, for myself, my life came full circle. At 17 years old, I went to the US Naval
Academy in Annapolis, Maryland, largely inspired by watching the original Top Gun. And then a couple
years ago, I had the opportunity, along with several of my other friends who became naval
aviators who were also in the movie because they used real-life naval aviators, we were all able to
appear in Top Gun Maverick. But interesting in that Top Gun Maverick is one of the films
they're always often talked about in the current controversy, isn't it? Because the patches on
Tom Cruise's jacket, which originally had flags representing Taiwan and Japan, appeared to have
been swapped out and replaced by ambiguous symbols. I'm so glad you brought it up because I think
it's really an example of this debate that we're having within the national security community.
There are some people who believe that that kind of censorship represents capitulating to China.
And I've taken the position that if we don't allow some compromise in American movies, especially
ones that are integrally related to US DoD and US military activities, are completely banned from
China, that will not serve our strategic goals. What you saw in Top Gun Maverick was you saw
an adjustment to appease Chinese censorship or Chinese pressure. But the overall impact was
that you got to see an American film about the world's most powerful military in Chinese theaters.
So for me, that kind of compromise is worth it. Mark Green, the politician who's pushing for this
change, has said it's censorship of American culture to edit these films for a Chinese audience.
I have absolute respect for Representative Green and for the mission that he's trying to accomplish.
We both have concerns about Chinese censorship of American culture. That being said,
what the Green Amendment does that he's proposed severely restricts American influence within
China. And frankly, it's doubling up. The Pentagon and the Department of Defense already has rules
that limit Chinese censorship for American movies. So this current bill, from my perspective, is
redundant and doesn't give the freedom and flexibility to what's actually a really important
tool in the information battle space for the Pentagon to use. The truth is, there's no
substitute for real life cooperation between Hollywood and the Department of Defense. The
more accurate and the more authentic we can make portrayals of the US military, the more powerful
the medium of filmmaking will be. Caj Larson, a military technical advisor talking to Martha
Kai. Archaeologists in Israel have discovered four ancient Roman swords in a cave in the desert.
They think the weapons were captured by Jewish rebels nearly 2000 years ago.
Here's our Middle East analyst, Sebastian Usher. The swords were found in a remote cave overlooking
the Dead Sea. At the entrance, a coin was also found from the time of a famous revolt by Jewish
fighters against Roman rule in what was then Judea. That's led the archaeologists who made the
discovery to herald it as a rare find that casts new light on the era. They believe that the ancient
swords may have been taken as booty from Roman soldiers on or off the battlefield. The Bar Kokba
revolt saw Jewish fighters take control of much of Judea for several years until the Roman Emperor
Hadrian brought the full force of the Imperial army down on the rebels, crushing them decisively.
Sebastian Usher. As with many sectors, the development of video games was hobbled by the
Covid pandemic, but the $300 billion industry has come roaring back with blockbuster releases like
Hogwarts Legacy, The Legend of Zelda and Final Fantasy XVI, with details of the latest title
hoping to get in on the action. Here's our gaming correspondent, Stefan Powell.
Starfield. A sprawling space epic. It's the big hope for Xbox in 2023.
Exclusive to that console, bosses hope it will be popular enough to help them claw back the gap
on the Sony PlayStation 5 which is outselling the competition. It's the brainchild of Todd Howard,
game director of some of the most critically acclaimed titles of recent history. Skyrim
and Fallout. Was the game in your head as ambitious as the game has ended up becoming?
I always start with a tone. Okay, we're going to go out in space, you have a ship, you can land on
planets and it has this kind of science fiction vibe. You know, it wasn't until later after we
finished Fallout 4, we really start designing where you realize how much you have to design. How
much space is big? How much space is in space? It ended up just, you know, so much larger than
anything we had ever done and there were periods where you're, are we in over our heads? What do
you say to those people that might argue that games have got too big? We found two things. One,
they do play it for a really, really long time, but even if they play it say for 10 hours or 20
hours and they finish the main quest and they save the world, whatever, that they see all the other
choices, that that experience, those 20 hours were different because they had so much choice.
Some critics have been impressed by this score and grandeur,
others have found it a little underwhelming and disjointed.
As an exclusive release, it's only available to Xbox and PC players.
Talking about audiences and who plays your game, do you think there is still
place in the industry for exclusive games like this? When you're making something,
the more you can focus, the more you know this is the hardware or the thing people are going to
play on, you know, your ability to focus on that always yields a better product.
Having spent five and a half billion pounds in 2020 on buying the studio that made the game,
Microsoft is waiting to see if Starfield can blast away the PlayStation's lead.
And that's all from us for now, but the global news podcast will be back very soon.
This edition was mixed by Caroline Driscoll and produced by Emma Joseph.
Our editors, Karen Martin, I'm Oliver Conway. Until next time, goodbye.
The world's wealthiest people did to get so ridiculously rich.
Our podcast, Good Bad Billionaire, takes one billionaire at a time and explains exactly
how they made their money. And then we decide if they are actually good, bad, or just plain wealthy.
So if you want to know if Rihanna is as much of a bad gal as she claims, or what Jeff Bezos really
did to become the first person in history to pocket a hundred billion dollars.
Listen to Good Bad Billionaire with me, Simon Jack.
And me, Xingxing, available now wherever you get your podcasts.
Machine-generated transcript that may contain inaccuracies.
They've done it without using sperm, eggs or a womb. Also: The US promises another billion dollars' worth of assistance for Ukraine - including depleted uranium ammunition for battle tanks, and the Rolling Stones unveil their first new album in 18 years.